Keurig K500 vs K575: Which Coffee Maker is the Best in 2020?


Our experts like to share product recommendations with you and hope you like them! Just to make you aware, CoffeeStoppe may collect a small share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page.

Keurig revolutionized the coffee industry when it introduced the K-Cup single serve brewing system, and with each new model comes new features and new bells and whistles that are meant to please coffee lovers everywhere.

The K500 is a much-beloved coffee maker. Even with newer models available, it has a following of users who prefer its simple elegance and easy to use design to the newer models being produced now.

Similarly, the K575 also has its fans. The K575 offers more options in terms of pour size and water temperature, but at the end of the day the K500 and the K575 are still the same machine and they perform the same function.

Keurig K500 vs K575: Which Coffee Maker is the Best?

In order to determine which coffee maker is the best, let’s take a look at both the Keurig K500 and the K575.

Keurig K500 Coffee Maker Single Serve Brewing System

Keurig K500 Coffee Maker Single Serve 2.0 Brewing System with Top Needle Cleaning Maintenance Accessory and My K-Cup Reusable Coffee Filter, Platinum

Buy on Amazon

Features:

  • 80 ounce water reservoir
  • Brewing strength control
  • Color touch display
  • Programmable timer allows for automatic brewing
  • Night light inside the water reservoir

Pros:

  • Works with My K-Cup reusable coffee filter
  • Quickly provides hot water whenever you need it
  • Touch display makes using the machine easier

Cons:

  • Older model doesn’t come supported by Keurig when shipped by third party vendors
  • Louder than newer models

Customer Feedback:

  • Even with filtered water, the coffee maker gets clogged frequently
  • Tank lid allows you to add more water without removing the entire lid, which is better than some of the other Keurig designs
  • Customer service is very helpful
  • The K500 model is better than the K550 which requires you to hold the lever down to produce hot water. You can get hot water with the push of a button with the K500

Buy on Amazon

Keurig K575 Single Serve Coffee Maker

Keurig K575 Coffee Maker, Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Brewer, Programmable Brewer, Platinum

Buy on Amazon

Features:

  • 80-ounce water reservoir, with a removable reservoir tank that also features a nightlight
  • Brews 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 ounce cups of coffee, and can also be used with a carafe when using K-Carafe pods (which are no longer available)
  • 5 temperature controls
  • Large color touch screen

Pros:

  • The K575 offers many options in terms of temperature and size of the cup being brewed
  • Easy to use color touch screen helps users find the proper temperature and size setting each time

Cons:

  • K Carafe pods are no longer available, making that function obsolete in this design

Customer Feedback:

  • Takes longer to brew and is louder than previous models
  • Placement of the water reservoir lid makes it easier to access from under the cupboards
  • Needles get jammed frequently, causing the pods to explode when improperly punctured

Buy on Amazon


How the K500 and K575 Compare to the K-Elite

While the K500 and K575 are still available through third party sellers, there is a newer Keurig model that has replaced both machines, the Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Brewer. Here’s what the K-Elite offers:

Keurig K-Elite Single Serve Brewer

Keurig K-Elite Coffee Maker, Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Brewer, With Iced Coffee Capability, Brushed Slate

Buy on Amazon

Features:

  • 75 ounce removable water reservoir, which allows for eight 8-ounce cups to be brewed
  • Removable drip tray allows travel mugs up to 7.2 inches in height, and it also holds a full brew in case of accidental brews
  • Provides a reminder about required maintenance
  • Quiet brew technology
  • Brews a variety of hot drinks, but also has the ability to make iced coffee
  • My K-Cup Universal Reusable Coffee Filter compatible so that ground coffee can be used

Pros:

  • Much quieter operation than earlier models
  • Brews faster with Smart Start, which heats the water and brews the coffee at the same time
  • Also makes iced coffee

Cons:

  • Does not work with a carafe

Customer Feedback:

  • Over 80% positive customer feedback of 4- and 5-star reviews
  • Much better than previous designs
  • Automatic brewing function saves time
  • Offers more brewing and size options than ever before, but the coffee maker is still easy to use
  • Great machine for people who have used Keurig before and are getting an upgraded model

Buy on Amazon


Verdict

The K500 offers a more consistent brewing experience, but the K575 offers more features. By contrast, the K-Elite, which replaces both models, seems to be the best of both worlds with peak performance and more options than ever before. Given that the K500 and K575 have been discontinued by Keurig and are only available from third party vendors, it would seem that the K-Elite is really the only choice if you are looking to purchase the newest model. However, for anyone who wants to go back to the earlier days of the Keurig, if you have to choose between the two older models, the K500 was the more consistent coffee maker. It offered fewer options, but it made a better cup of coffee thanks to its simplicity. And since Keurig no longer manufactures K Carafe pods, a large chunk of the K575’s function is now obsolete.